So, if government is really serious about blocking the blasphemous content on youtube, they must resort to methods like url filtering instead of blocking the whole website. When people from Pakistan open youtube from a proxy server or a VPN it not only opens the whole website up but also opens that blasphemous content as well for the users. So it is very important that the whole website is unbanned and only the objectionable material like blasphemous content is blocked.
From attitudes of PTA and government its been clear that the people they have hired are not capable of effective url filtering, also somehow url filtering from these currents techs in government industry of Pakistan would only worsen the things and make the things much more annoyingly slow. So government have a good alternative to that as well, that is having a contract with Google Inc, pay them the security money they demand for contract and then they will effectively block all objectionable videos and their copies for the government of Pakistan.
Lets see how Pakistanis are losing from youtube ban.
There is an ocean of educational content available on youtube, for a person or a student who does not want bypass the ban by government or does not know how to do it, this material is inaccessible. I know people who have been benifiiting with this material a lot and learned from it a lot in the Past. Quality of education in not so good in Pakistan, specially higher education, so people have been benefiting form the material available on youtube. Now that material is not available for Pakistanis and citizens of other countries are learning benefiting from them. Most of Islamic countries have done those contracts with youtube or with private url filtering they blocked only the objectionable content and rest of site is available.
I belong to information technology (IT) field, in fact I am web applications developer. I know it better than anyone else fr an IT professional it is very important to stay updated with the latest technologies, our development tools are ever changing and if we close eye to them for a day, we are far behind than everyone else in the world. Pakistan does not have that kind of IT institutions which teach or guide the people with the latest technology. so we have to resort to online tutorials. Also everyone knows that no other website have latest tutorials like youtube, its used by so many more people compared to other websites, so that people don’t even post those videos on other small websites of the world.
Now, not only this site contains tutorials about the everything else, it tells you how to repair your tv, how to fix tv cable, how to fix anything, even how to stitch clothes and how to make artwork that is sell-able. I have come across so many success stories about people who learned stuff from youtube and earning a fortune through it.
We can hear but can’t Speak out hearts out
Remember, in start of post I had talked of people who can access website through proxies and VPN. But we all Pakistanis can not post any video on youtube. That means world can speak, we can hear them but we can’t speak what we have to. I know channels on youtube which have been preaching Islam and have been preaching good image of Pakistan, but now through all those proxies we can only hear what others have to say about us but we can’t balance that out with our prospective of thing.
It would be considered as biggest failure of current Pakistani government lead by PML-N if they could not treat this issue of blanket banning the youtube. All those students as well as, freelancers and technical people who are earning money from other countries and bringing in lots of revenue, they are all in trouble due to this ban. Government will have to be friendly with IT sector as well as with the students.
Feel free to share your opinions about this issue. Do follow/Like us on twitter and Facebook using the options on right side of this page to keep yourself updated with latest information and happenings.
Pakistani Govts r so incapable that they have only one option for whatever the thing is block or ban……Act of blasphemy YOUTUBE banned…..Act of TERROISM….cellular services block…..They have no plans on what they are going to achieve by all this….Its like the same that because there are road accidents,stop driving the cars……….INFACT the real thing is try to find out the root cause and eliminate the main problem…..Youtube ban has let to proxy usage and now Most ppl are aware of total filter free internet….which itself is a shame on Govt side and a complete failure of policy…..
Yes, thats the point, so we are absolutely gaining nothing from this ban. Only just Pakistanis are deprived of uploading their videos to site and speak their point of view out to the world.
Its just matter of not having right people on right positions/posts, which makes whole system disaster.
then what the heck is that hunnnnn
but ill be clear im not a pml n supporter
Youtube.com is still blocked till this moment, on ptcl however you could open the site by adding https:// in the start of url instead of http://, however no video can be run. Also government still needs those approvals from Prime Minister and stuff, so these are just initial decision which need approval. So they are not implemented yet. They will be implemented after approval and after official notifications are sent to ISPs.